Kemal Akay

Societies of Control and Games

Game Analysis

Yorum Yapılmamış

Share this post

The agency of interactivity, called as player, is indispensable part of the video games. Games are required to be played and unlike any other medium, games can tell their stories via physical interactivity based on non-linear actions of player. In some ways, it is possible to interpret games as mirrors. All the actions of player are reflected on the virtual environment inside the frame of screen. Inevitably, the way player interacts with virtual world is interpreted through the semiotic structure of game. The control of player over the screen is therefore represented by allegories. Although this is what Deleuze might have analyzed under his concept ‘action-image’, we will examine another theory of him, Socities of Control in relation to games.


In Postscript on the Societies of Control, Deleuze talks about three different types of society. Inspired by Foucault, he defines society of sovereignty, disciplinary society and control society. As a summary, a society of sovereignty is what he calls the political structure established in medieval ages and disciplinary society is the period where radical politic changes occured after industrial revolution and names Napoléon and Nazi periods as examples. Our primary concern is, in our case, societies of control and Deleuze declares that nowadays a system is being established where everything is manipulated for keeping the society under control. For instance, Deleuze gives highways as an example. Think about them for a moment. Back then, it was possible for  drivers to create their own route, but now, even though highways seem to make the road experience more comfortable, they are also limiting the amount of alternative routes. Deleuze says this might not have been thought directly, but on subconscious level, this is a result of what they want to establish.

In essence, the development of games theory, system theory and all similar mathematical theories in the mid-20 century aimed to reduce human equation into statistical data and geometrical models and created a metaphorical ‘cage’ for the society. Now in the post-industrial era, the corporation has replaced factory in which every individual is considered as employees or units rather than factory workers. Deleuze expands his concept: “If the most idiotic television game shows are so successful, it’s because they express the corporate situation with great precision.” Just as there is a competitive challenge between corporations, there is also a motivation that enforces individuals to oppose each other and compete against, which ends up dividing them as a result.

In the age of computation, human became nothing more than pure data and fleshless code. It is now possible to track your every movement on the net (unless you use Ghostery plug-in) and corporations like Google and Twitter are storing them to create profiles of human entities, then transform these statistics into meta products and sell them to third party companies with high amount of money in return. Every data you produce is used against you, not only to track but also to modify your thoughts and make you become an integrated part of system.


Alexander Galloway draws a similar picture and says that in ideological/traditional allegory, emblematic medium was cinema and the political expression was class struggle. Now in control allegory, the emblematic medium becomes video games and at present, political expression is information control. Likewise, he said “While it may appear liberating or utopian, don’t be fooled; flexibility is one of the founding principles of global informatic control. It is to the control society what discipline was to a previous one. Just as medieval scholars used the existence of contradiction in a text as an indication of existence of allegory, so Civilization game has within its many contradictions that suggest such an allegorical interpretation.” That’s why he called Civilization game as an ‘allegorithm’. Flexibility and allegory, supported by vicarious kinaesthesia, create a so-called ”independence” in games. Many games take the ‘critical approach’ away. And as Mathieu Triclot said “Video games are small dust of dream by which the big sleep of capitalism is shaken, things that are dreams connected to the numerical machines.”

Only a few games like Metal Gear Solid 2 takes a one step further and tells you to “Turn Off the Game Console Right Now!”


1) Deleuze, Gilles. Postscript on the Societies of Control (1992)

2) Galloway, Alexander. Gaming: Essays on Algorithmic Culture (2006)

3) Triclot, Mathieu. La Philosophie des Jeux Vidéo (2011)

4) Deleuze, Guattari: Societies of Control and Antipsychiatry (URL)


this post için 0 cevap
Add your comment